I think I have had this one rattle on for a bit too long, almost two months. I am going to post the picks of the top five guys to play Ian O’Shea, and then I will list the names of other actors that got a vote.
The obvious #1 choice was Ian Somerhalder.
Chace Crawford, who would not be my choice. He is too pretty.
Wentworth Miller–the guy just needs to let his hair grow in and get away from the Prison Break look.
Other choices: James Franco, Erik Fellows, Mark Whalberg (too old, I think), and Channing Tatum.
Feel free to add more suggestions in the comments section or whether you agree or disagree with any of the selections. Thanks!